[openib-general] [PATCH v3 0/6] Tranport Neutral Verbs Proposal.

[Krishna Kumar2]

Hi James,

Sorry for the late response, my system was down and I just got it fixed.

> Is there a benefit to having rdmav_create_qp() take generic 
> parameters if the application needs to understand the type of QP (IB, 
> iWARP, etc.) created and the transport specific communication manager 
> calls that are needed to manipulate it?
> 
> Would it make more sense if the QP create command was also transport 
> specific?

My opinion is that the create_qp taking generic parameters is correct, 
only
subsequent calls may need to use transport specific calls/arguments. 
Infact
rdma_create_qp uses the ibv_create_qp (now changed to rdmav_create_qp)
call internally.

PS : What is the opinion on this patchset ?

Thanks,

- KK