[ofa-general] Re: [PATCH 0/3] ib/ipoib: Enable IPoIB-UD 4K MTU support

[Or Gerlitz]

Shirley Ma wrote:
> On Thu, 2008-01-31 at 09:04 +0200, Or Gerlitz wrote:

>> I see, but I want to make sure these patches are the one you want to 
>> merge into the kernel or its more of a work in progress which you want 
>> to be included in this experimental testbed called ofed.

> I will create patch for OFED-1.3-RC3 separately. I wouldn't call it's
> experimental code since these APIs have been tested along with IPoIB-CM
> already. They are pretty stable.

I meant to say that ofed is an experimental testbed, this is becoming 
more and more clear to more and more people. I did not address your 
patchset specifically.

>> If its candidate for upstream inclusion, I find it hard to review since 
>> there is no per patch change-log.

> Thanks for the advice, I thought one change log was enough. If not, I
> will resubmit these patches along with one ling change-log.

If you think that for each of the patch one line change log is enough 
for a reviewer, let it be, but if I were you, I would validate again 
this assumption. The things is that when you send an RFC, many times 
most of the documentation is in the virtual 0/N patch, but remember that 
  this documentation does not go into the git change-log, so in your 
case since you want this to be merged, you have to work harder and 
document both in the 0/N and also in the 1/N, 2/N ... N/N postings.

Or