[Iwg-arbitration-committee] FW: UNH-IOL OFA Logo Reports

[Rupert Dance]

Hello Jeff,

The Arbitration Committee meet last week and reviewed your request.
Arbitration requests are usually submitted when a product fails during the
Logo Event. In your case the device passed but UNH-IOL added comments to
avoid a failure if someone were to try and replicate the results using the
version of the test plan in effect at the time. So this was not a failure on
the part of your product and some felt Pass with Comments was appropriate.

We nonetheless understood your concern that there is possible inference that
your device was not given an unqualified pass. So we all agreed to support
your request to change the result to a Pass but we will keep the comment in
place to avoid any chance of confusion for the end user as noted above.
UNH-IOL will be sending an updated report to you.

Thank you for your participation in the OFILG.

Rupert Dance
OFA Director of Training and Quality Assurance
Software Forge 
2 Greenleaf Woods Drive #301
Portsmouth, NH 03801
Phone: 603-319-8486
www.soft-forge.com



-----Original Message-----
From: iwg-arbitration-committee-bounces at lists.openfabrics.org
[mailto:iwg-arbitration-committee-bounces at lists.openfabrics.org] On Behalf
Of Kopko, Jeff
Sent: Friday, May 10, 2013 3:26 PM
To: iwg-arbitration-committee at openfabrics.org
Cc: Nate Rubin (nrubin at iol.unh.edu)
Subject: [Iwg-arbitration-committee] FW: UNH-IOL OFA Logo Reports

Hello,

Emulex would like have our results for MPI reviewed.

Current Reported Results for test 13.7 MPI  = Pass with Comments

Desired Results = Pass

Reasoning:

The issue is that the Global Routing Header will not be set if rdmacm is not
specified for openmpi.  GRH is required for RoCE.
 
Spec Details.
In current OFED stack implementation, to comply to RDMA RoCE Annex
specification, To satisfy requirement CA16-4. And CA16-22, rdmacm is
necessary.

Please let Emulex know if you are in agreement or if you require and further
information from us.

Thank you,
- Jeff



-----Original Message-----
From: Nate Rubin [mailto:nrubin at iol.unh.edu] 
Sent: Thursday, May 02, 2013 1:48 PM
To: Kopko, Jeff
Cc: OFA Lab Mailing List
Subject: UNH-IOL OFA Logo Reports

Jeff,

Attached you will find the RoCE reports for this February's Logo Event.

If you would like can file an arbitration request by emailing
"iwg-arbitration-committee at openfabrics.org" within 14 days of receiving this
email.

Please let me know if you have any questions.

Thanks,
Nate Rubin


Attachment saved to
<file:///C:\Users\rsdance\Documents\Lamprey\OpenIB\Groups\IWG\Plugfest\2012-
10\Arbitration\Emulex\OFILG_2013-Feb_Logo-Report_Emulex_Beta_v1.0.pdf>