[openib-general] DAPL for openib

Roland Dreier roland at topspin.com
Tue Aug 24 08:54:34 PDT 2004


    Roland> - Finish new MAD API (stalled?)

    Hal> Can you elaborate on what you mean by this ? Are there API
    Hal> issues (other than the ones deferred) or is this referring to
    Hal> an implementation to go with the API ?

I haven't been following this very closely but I didn't feel we had
reached a final form of the API, and Sean's ib_mad.h has not been
updated for several weeks.  Also (correct me if I'm wrong) you seem to
be working on an implementation of a different API.

Also, I can think of at least one issue with the ib_mad.h API, and
other people probably have their own issues.  My question is how we
should split SM class queries such as PortInfo, which go to the SMA,
from queries such as SMInfo, which needs to be passed to userspace to
be handled by the SM.  Right now the ib_mad_reg() call just takes
class, version and method, but both PortInfo and SMInfo will be
identical in those attributes.

 - Roland



More information about the general mailing list